Commentary: Who profits from 'crimmigration'? Not America or its ideals

Commentary: Who profits from 'crimmigration'? Not America or its ideals

  • 0
San Diego Fire Rescue worked with Border Patrol to rescue 20 people from a drainage tube about two miles west of the San Ysidro Port of Entry on Thanksgiving night, November 28, 2019, after they tried to enter the country illegally and became trapped in rushing water.

San Diego Fire Rescue worked with Border Patrol to rescue 20 people from a drainage tube about two miles west of the San Ysidro Port of Entry on Thanksgiving night, November 28, 2019, after they tried to enter the country illegally and became trapped in rushing water. (United States Border Patrol/TNS)

The world watched in horror last year as the Trump administration's zero tolerance policy left thousands of children separated from their parents with many held in cages at the border. But what was lost in the outrage was that while unconscionable and inhumane, the family separation policy was just a grotesque extension of a decadeslong shift to criminalizing immigration, a practice known as "crimmigration."

Crimmigration - advanced by both Democratic and Republican administrations - is the intersection of immigration and criminal law, and while most alive today don't remember any other way, it is a relatively new phenomenon in the U.S. It can be traced back to the early 1980s when "crime" became used as a surrogate for race as a more socially acceptable rationale for "get tough" policies that disproportionately targeted Black and Latino people and led to the explosion of mass incarceration.

Under the crimmigration system, migrants are incarcerated for trying to come to the United States, over 100,000 in 2018 alone. A multitude of offenses large and small are increasingly deemed "aggravated felonies" to create a rationale for detaining undocumented immigrants. Asylum seekers are imprisoned for following the law and showing up in person to make their claim for safe harbor. This, against a backdrop of an immigration process that is prohibitively difficult to successfully navigate under "legal" processes.

University of Denver law professor Cesar Cuauhtemoc Garcia Hernandez, author of the new book "Migrating to Prison," said it's critical to understand this approach is not just the natural order.

"We now think of immigration prisons as essential to a functioning immigration law enforcement system," Garcia Hernandez said. "But the reality is that between the mid-1950s and the late 1970s, we didn't really lock people up. For 25 years or so ... the United States got really close to shutting down its immigration prison system. And the country did not come tumbling down."

Today, the U.S. has the world's largest immigrant detention system, according to the Global Detention Project, holding over 50,000 people a day in a network of jails and private detention centers.

U.S. immigration policy has always been underpinned by racism and xenophobia - manifested in policies like the white-male-only citizenship act of 1790 or the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 - but the current immigrant mass detention system brought on by crimmigration is nothing like we have seen before.

One reason for this move to mass detention is that there are a multitude of entities making money off the industry. Private detention companies like GEO Group and CoreCivic (formerly Corrections Corporation of America/CCA) treat humans confined in their detention centers as commodities. Profiting from lucrative government contracts, they make money backward and forward: first, from contracts to hold 71% of the country's immigrant detainees and then from having detainees do the center's basic labor for $1 a day. Many rural towns and counties vie fiercely for detention centers for the jobs and taxes they bring.

While much is made about Seattle and other cities' sanctuary policies, our neighbor to the south, Tacoma, is home to the Northwest Detention Center, which ICE has now renamed the Northwest ICE Processing Center. One of the GEO Group's private detention centers, the facility holds up to 1,575 immigrants and was the subject of a detainee hunger strike last year as well as a state lawsuit over the detention center wages.

Maru Mora-Villalpando is an undocumented activist with the group La Resistencia, which supports the efforts of those detained at the center for better conditions and to stop deportations. She and La Resistencia want to see the detention center shut down and are joined by 140 organizations and counting who support that effort.

Today's immigration detention system is just an extension of the overall criminal justice system, Mora-Villalpando said. "Once we understand that the prison system is already a system of oppression against people of color, then you'll understand why (immigration) was criminalized. Because it was really easy then to excuse having people detained."

It's long past time to challenge our policymakers about our crimmigration system and shift our thinking as a society. Whose interests does it serve to detain hundreds of thousands of people at a financial price tag of $3 billion a year and incalculable human cost? How does it increase public safety? How does it align with a vision of a United States where immigrants are welcome? What would you do if your family was fleeing war or poverty?

What Garcia Hernandez calls the "invisible giant" of immigrant detention that grew to historic levels under President Barack Obama, is now fueled by the Trump and Fox News rhetoric of dangerous and criminal "illegal aliens" as well as policies crafted by white nationalist-linked Stephen Miller.

But with public attention and calls for change, Garcia Hernandez said, this does not have to be our future. "We've gone from almost no immigration prisoners to almost half a million immigration prisoners (a year)," he said. "If we can do that in my lifetime, I'm hopeful that we can undo that in my lifetime."



Naomi Ishisaka ( is a columnist for the Seattle Times.

Visit The Seattle Times at


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

It bears repeating: Donald Trump was not only press-ganging Volodymyr Zelenskiy in an illegal scheme for partisan gain. He was rewriting the history of 2016 in order to wound enemies (Democrats) and help friends (Vladimir Putin) - as well as to give Kremlin operatives room to strike again. It is in no way overstating the case to say the president of the United States is the head of an ...

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy delivered an unmistakable rebuke to President Trump in an interview published Monday by Time and three European news outlets. Then Trump, as is his wont, declared himself totally exonerated. According to the partial transcript posted by Time, Zelenskiy mostly discussed the war with Russian-backed rebels along Ukraine's eastern border. When he got onto ...

It looks like a "witch hunt" has found another witch. U.S. Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-Calif.), embattled over allegations of misusing campaign funds to pay for family trips, personal clothes (allegedly masked as a donation to a veterans group) and trysts with at least five women, appeared in federal court in San Diego on Tuesday to change his not guilty plea. Hunter pled guilty to a single count of ...

When a fresh news poll finds that a majority of Republicans believe that Donald Trump is a better president than Abraham Lincoln was, what's an old-school, never-Trump Republican to do? For Rick Wilson, it's more of the same, with even more fire and fury - talking on television, and writing another book. The new one, "Running Against the Devil," is out next month, and in it, the veteran GOP ...

  • Updated

Here's a scary look at the future for Democrats and, well, the country. As the Democratic-controlled House moves toward impeaching President Donald Trump - a step it was compelled to take by Trump's blatant abuse of power - it could well be putting in motion events that will leave the president scarred but also empowered in dangerous ways. The House Judiciary Committee is in all likelihood ...

Asian Americans are often invisible in American culture, and judging by the experience of presidential candidate Andrew Yang, even more so in politics. Many Asian Americans will relate: White people regularly cut ahead of me in line and then are surprised when I call them out. My Korean American assistant recently reported that a man tried to walk through her on the sidewalk as if she wasn't ...

For all the fears that the U.S. and China are unwinding the economic ties that drove decades of global prosperity, it's striking how much recent optimism depends upon the two countries. Just months ago, all the talk was about recession, stocks were tanking and tariffs flew back and forth across the Pacific. Now the S&P 500 is reaching record highs, global growth outlooks have steadied and ...

"Thank you for your service." Our troops hear that often from their fellow Americans, and not just during the holiday season. Well, our gratitude can go even deeper. We can also be thankful that they are not fighting "endless wars." Calls for "no more endless wars" may be catchy, but they're a bumper-stick excuse for a serious foreign policy. Sure, there are many intractable conflicts around ...

  • Updated

LOS ANGELES - It seemed fitting somehow that the news of Kamala Harris' withdrawal from the presidential race would be quickly blotted out Tuesday by the House Intelligence Committee's release of its impeachment report. Even in retreat, Harris couldn't hold onto the spotlight. Ten months ago, Harris made a sizzling debut as a Democratic presidential contender, quickly becoming the most popular ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alert

Breaking News