RACINE COUNTY — Students who attended private schools on vouchers, instead of Racine Unified schools, on average performed more poorly than their district peers on the Wisconsin Knowledge and Concepts Exam.

The Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction Tuesday released a comparison of private school choice students and public school students on the WKCE. The test was given to grades three through eight and 10 last fall.

For Racine Unified, 60 of the 62 private school choice students in those grades were tested, DPI stated. They averaged 50.8 percent proficient or advanced on the WKCE math tests, while Unified students averaged 61.5 percent.

Those private school choice students also scored well below the state average math proficiency of 78.0 and the statewide average for economically disadvantaged students, 64.7 percent, DPI said.

In reading, the private school choice students from Unified averaged 55.7 percent proficient or advanced, compared with the district average of 69.2 percent.

The statewide average was 81.9 percent proficiency in reading and 70.5 percent for economically disadvantaged students.

This is the first year of the voucher program for Racine Unified School District.

About the results, Unified Superintendent Ann Laing responded, “Basically, the scores speak for themselves.”

“And I think when schools take public money, they have to understand there’s some public accountability,” Laing continued. “I think we all have to be held accountable at the same level, with the same tests.”

Told of the results, school vouchers champion state Rep. Robin Vos, R-Rochester, said, “I would say that is exactly why we started school choice in Racine. What these test results prove is that Unified failed them.”

Those students now have a better chance at a good education, he said.

Asked how long it might be before results show that kind of improvement over public school students, Vos replied, “I think it will be five to 10 years before we can consistently say a child who goes to a choice school has a better chance for success.”

State tax dollars fund both the Milwaukee and Racine voucher programs which allow students who meet income guidelines to attend private schools. Laing noted the family household income limit to be in the program is $67,000, which she said is considerably greater than the city of Racine family median income.

The DPI said Unified’s new private school voucher program is receiving $1.5 million in state tax dollars while Unified is receiving $16.4 million less in state and categorical aid this school year, a 10.3 percent reduction.



Unified students: 69.2 

Choice school students: 55.7 


Unified students: 61.5

Choice school students: 50.8

The Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction Tuesday released a comparison of private school choice students within the Racine Unified School District and public school students within the district on a standardized test. The test was given to grades three through eight and 10 last fall.

(1) comment


I'm new in town, but even I can see how lopsided this article was. Three simple points: In March of 2012 the Choice students who were tested had been in their new school only one year. The pool of 60 total students was extremely small. The families who chose to leave, were among the least satisfied with the educational product their child was receiving and they may have been among the lowest performing students in the district (I don't know this to be a fact, but as a parent and teacher it sounds reasonable.)
Let's see what takes place over the next few years with larger numbers of students involved. Of course soon the WKCE is going to be replaced by a new test. Regardless of what happens we need to have the means for a true "apples-to-apples" comparison. Our families deserve nothing less.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.